I think we can all agree that a cabin in the woods equals creepy. Things definitely become creepier when hooded priests drinking from chalices are involved. The blond guy seems fully aware of this right from the get-go; even before he almost drowns during the baptism ritual. Actually, he looks pretty concerned throughout the entire video.
Brooklyn’s Ski Lodge do a great impression of The Smiths, from the upbeat guitars and the gloomy lyrics to Andrew Marr’s Morrissey-esque wail. By the way, did you notice the last name? The Smiths connection continues.